If you are behind on mortgage payments in Indiana, you still have options, and you have more of them the earlier you act. Most homeowners can talk to their lender about a repayment plan, forbearance or a loan modification, and some decide that selling the house, on their own terms, is the better path.
Quick answer
Behind on your mortgage in Lake, Porter, Jasper or LaPorte County? Open every letter, call your lender’s loss mitigation team, and talk to a free housing counselor. Your main options are catching up with a repayment plan, a short pause called forbearance, a loan modification, a short sale, or selling the house while you still have equity. Indiana foreclosures go through the courts, so there is usually time to choose, but the earlier you start, the more choices you keep.
Missing a payment can feel like a door closing. It is not. Lenders deal with late payments every day, and federal and Indiana rules build in steps before any foreclosure can move forward. Here is what those steps are, what each option means in plain English, and how to pick the one that fits your situation.
What Happens When You Fall Behind on Mortgage Payments in Indiana
Most loans have a short grace period, then a late fee. After that, your servicer will call and send letters about your options. Under federal mortgage servicing rules, a servicer generally cannot make the first legal filing for foreclosure until you are more than 120 days behind. Use that four-month window to work things out.
Indiana adds its own protections. Before a lender files a foreclosure case, it must mail you a pre-suit notice at least 30 days ahead. That notice explains your rights and lists the Indiana Foreclosure Prevention Network, which offers free counseling at 1-877-GET-HOPE and 877GetHope.org. If a case is filed, the court papers tell you that you can ask for a settlement conference with the lender. You generally have 30 days after you receive the summons to request one.
Foreclosure in Indiana is a court process, filed in the county where the house sits, such as Lake or Porter County. If you want to see each stage laid out, read our Indiana foreclosure timeline.
What to do now: Open every letter. Write down every date. Call your servicer and ask for the loss mitigation department.
Your Options for Keeping the House
Repayment plan
You pay your normal payment plus a bit extra each month until you are caught up. This tends to fit when the problem was short, like a few weeks off work, and your income is back to normal.
Forbearance
Your lender lets you pause or lower payments for a set time. The skipped amount does not go away. You will need to repay it later, in a lump sum, a repayment plan, or added to the loan. Ask exactly how it will be repaid before you agree.
Loan modification
The lender changes the loan itself, such as the interest rate, the length of the loan, or how the past-due amount is handled, so the payment fits your budget. You usually have to send a full application with pay stubs, bank statements and a hardship letter. Send everything the lender asks for, keep copies, and follow up in writing.
Reinstatement
If you can pay everything you owe, including late fees and costs, you can bring the loan current. In Indiana, catching up this way can stop the case or the sheriff’s sale. Ask the lender for a written reinstatement quote with a good-through date.
A free counselor can help you see which of these is realistic. You can also find HUD-approved housing counselors on HUD’s website. Watch out for anyone who asks for money up front to “save” your house. Real help is usually free.
Your Options if Keeping the House Is Not Realistic
Sometimes the numbers just do not work, even with help. A job change, a divorce, medical bills or a house that needs more repairs than you can afford can all make staying hard. That is not a failure. It is a decision, and you still get to make it.
Sell the house while you have equity
If your home is worth more than you owe, selling lets you pay off the loan, past-due amounts and fees at closing, and keep what is left. The title company pays the lender directly. You can list with an agent if you have time and the house is in good shape, or sell as-is to a cash buyer if you need a set date or the house needs work.
Short sale
If you owe more than the house is worth, the lender may agree to take less than the full payoff. Short sales need lender approval and can take months, so start early. Ask the lender, in writing, whether it will forgive the rest of the balance or keep the right to collect it.
Deed in lieu of foreclosure
You sign the house over to the lender instead of going through foreclosure. Lenders do not always agree, and you usually give up any equity. Get the terms in writing before you sign.
How to Choose: Behind on Mortgage Payments Checklist
- Is the problem short or long? Short problems fit repayment plans and forbearance. Long ones may need a modification or a sale.
- Can you afford the new payment? Be honest. A plan you cannot keep only delays the same problem.
- Do you have equity? Look up what similar homes nearby sold for and compare it with your payoff. Equity gives you more choices.
- Has a sheriff’s sale date been set? If so, time matters. Every option, including selling, must happen before that date. See what you can still do at each step in our guide to selling your house before foreclosure in Indiana.
- Do you want to stay? If you love the home and a modification can work, try that first.
Selling is not the right answer for everyone. If a counselor or your lender can get you to a payment you can keep, staying may be the better move.
How Selling to a Local Cash Buyer Works
If you decide to sell, here is how it works with us. A team member calls to learn about the house and your situation. We do one walkthrough, then give you a written cash offer and show how we got to the number. There are no commissions or fees, we pay the closing costs, and you do not need to make repairs or clean out the house. A local title company pays off your mortgage and any past-due amounts at closing. You pick the closing date, as little as 3-5 business days* or later if you need more time. If you would come out ahead by listing, we will tell you. Read more about selling a house in foreclosure in Northwest Indiana.
Preferred Home Buyer has been buying houses in Merrillville, Gary, Hammond, Crown Point, Valparaiso, Portage and the rest of Northwest Indiana since 2011. We have bought 1,050+ homes and are rated A+ by the BBB.
Frequently Asked Questions
Get a Fair Cash Offer
If you are behind on your mortgage and want to compare selling against your other options, we can give you real numbers. Get a fair cash offer or call (219) 348-8098. It is free, confidential and there is no obligation.
This is general information, not legal or tax advice. For advice about your loan or court case, talk to a HUD-approved housing counselor or an Indiana attorney.